*Bun in the Oven* Cookie recipe
Bun in the Oven cookies are cookies with a brownie hidden inside! I didn’t like the original name, Pillow Cookies. Or the alternate, Brookies. Of course I asked for help from my facebook friends on a much cooler name! Tyler said I should just call them Cookies with brownies inside. Sigh…no fun! I was looking at them and thought, it looks like a cookie is carrying a brownie love child. I know, I know….. So I must give credit where credit is due! Thanks to my old high school friend, Michelle (McKeal) Stafford, for the name of this cookie! I didn’t invent the idea of the cookie though, I got it off of Bakerella’s website. But the recipes I’m going to share with you are ALL ME! Like I said, I give credit where credit is due. I made Heath Toffee chip cookies with a Blondie brownie inside. Really though, you could use any combo of cookie and brownie flavors. Oh, and these guys are really big, they only make about 8-10 cookies.
So, first you need to make a cookie dough. This is my tried and true basic recipe.
2-1/4 cups All Purpose flour
1 tsp Baking Soda
1 tsp Salt
Combine dry ingredients in a bowl and set aside
1 cup Butter flavored Crisco Shortning
3/4 cup Brown sugar
3/4 cup White sugar
2 tsp Real Vanilla Extract (if you use imitation, I can not be held responsible for the results, hehe)
Mix above ingredients with an electric mixer until, well, it’s all mixed. Now you need 2 eggs. Add them ONE AT A TIME not sure why but it makes a difference. Mix well before adding the 2nd egg. Then slowly add the flour mixture until it’s all incorporated. I actually needed to add a bit more flour, only for the purpose of these particular cookies. So maybe about….. 1/4 cup or so. You don’t want these puppies to spread out too much. Then add in your Heath Toffee chips (or whatever you chose) then put all the dough in an air tight bowl and place in the fridge for at least 1 hour. I left mine overnight and it was fine.
While that’s chilling, make your brownies. I used a Butterscotch/Blondie type recipe.
1/4 cup Butter flavored Crisco
1 cup Brown sugar
2 tsp Real Vanilla
1 egg
3/4 cup All purpose flour
1 tsp Baking powder
1/2 tsp salt
Heat oven to 350. Grease 8×8 pan. Add brown sugar, vanilla and egg into mixer, melt the shortening then add that in the bowl and mix together. Stir in flour and baking powder. Pour into pan and bake for 25-30 minutes. Sometimes it seems like it’s still undercooked but the outside keeps getting darker and darker. Be careful now, take it out before it burns, trust me, if it still seems not done, just wait till it cools. It’s fine :)
Ok, so brownies are cooled and cut into little 1 inch squares, and cookie dough is chilled. Now for the fun! Turn on the oven to 375 and cover your baking sheets with parchment. Take a 1/3 cup measuring cup and pack it full of dough, use a spoon. Then turn out the dough onto your parchment and make an indent with your fingers. Place a brownie in the indent and just kind of squish it down, bring the sides of the dough up and roll it all until the brownie is covered and you have a big dough ball. Don’t place any more than 4 onto the sheet or they’ll stick together. Bake for about 15 minutes, then let cool on sheet. Place on cooling rack once you can get it off the sheet without it totally falling apart :) And then eat! But if you eat more than one, you’ll probably get sick, I’m just sayin’. Let me know if you make these and what you think! Like I said, any kind of cookie and brownie combo will do! Ok, now for some pictures!

































